Captain Cookie & the Milkman

Had chocolate chip ice cream sandwich and double chocolate ice cream sandwich. Service was good but lines was long. Guys working were nice. Some sitting area upstairs and additional seating in market. The day we went they were making more chocolate chip cookies so it was a 20 min wait. They were also not making shakes that day. It's a busy location. In walking distance from where we were staying.

My office building hired them to cater an ice cream social event. I got a snickerdoodle and strawberry ice cream sandwich. It was delicious. The strawberry ice cream did not look like the usual neon pink frozen dairy dessert flavored with high fructose corn syrup. It was just ice cream mixed with strawberry, so it just had the pale color of cream, but tasted like the strawberry ice cream you know and love.

The ice cream was absolutely delicious! Very creamy and sweet. I tried both the peach and salted caramel flavors. I got the salted caramel, but I still dream of peach haha. Will definitely get that next time. My main regret is that my snickerdoodle cookie was cold. Asked to warm it up but apparently they don't do that. And although I came here a few minutes to closing there still was a good number of people there, so I can't imagine how it would be during the day. Especially considering how small the place is. Lastly, I thought the color changing spoon was a cute touch.

Captain Cookie and the Milkman were a huge hit at our wedding! The cookie ice cream sandwiches were absolutely delicious—definitely a standout treat that our guests couldn't stop raving about. Each sandwich was a perfect blend of soft, flavorful cookies and creamy ice cream, making for an indulgent and memorable dessert experience. Our driver was incredibly kind and added to the fun atmosphere of the evening. To top it all off, he even sent us home with a batch of cookies, which was such a thoughtful gesture and greatly appreciated. If you’re looking for a unique and tasty addition to your event, Captain Cookie and the Milkman are a fantastic choice. Their treats and warm service made our special day even sweeter. Highly recommend!

We wanted some dessert one night and tried out this place. The strawberry ice cream wasn't nasty but had 0 flavor. The cookie was simply decent. I wouldn't come back.

Cookies have an absolute banger of a taste and are quite popular in the Western Market. The lines move quickly and while the prices are higher than what is used to you, the makeup is very acceptable and would return again. Much recommended for Foggy Bottom.

Good cookies! The service can be a little slow at times and the cookies are sometimes not as fresh as the last time you visited, but it's relatively cheap and open late.